While the good Cardinals must try to determine the identity of those cardinals who have been latae sententiae excommunicated, it is not my understanding that the reality of the excommunication, in fact, requires “due process” or that
it is “rash judgment” in every case for a member of the faithful, especially a lay
person, to make a private determination in conscience that the last supposed
conclave was null and void. It is true that, but for the gravest reasons, a lay
person should not proclaim or publicize such a judgment unless and until the
College of Cardinals exercises their ongoing competence to make those
necessary judgments within their canonical jurisdiction. But, a priest, for
example, who is offered a Bergoglian appointment as a bishop could and
should rightly arrive at the conclusion that any putative Bergoglian
pontifical mandate supposedly appointing him as a bishop would be null and
void, and without stating that, in conscience simply decline being elevatedto the office of bishop. And, without an eventual (sooner rather than later)
rectification of the College of Cardinals membership, the undeclared real
invalidity will spread to the point that The Church is both without a valid
Successor of Saint Peter, and absent divine intervention in human history,
without any valid mechanism to obtain a new Successor of Saint Peter.
This situation would leave the world, the human race, without the grace
of The Papacy, but with a randomly (e.g., some Catholic, some Orthodox)
valid episcopal hierarchy suchwise that we can synthesize two superficiallyopposing prophecies: the prophecy that Our Lord Jesus will remain with
us in the Sacraments, especially The Eucharist [“And behold, I (in The Most Blessed Sacrament) am with you always, untilthe end of the age.” Matthew 28:20b (NAB)],
with the prophecy stated in the Catechism of the Catholic Church, ¶677
[“The Church will enter the glory of the kingdom only through this final Passover,
when she will follow her Lord in his death and Resurrection. . . . God’s triumph
over the revolt of evil will take the form of the Last Judgment after the final cosmic
upheaval of this passing world.”] The Church then, in a very real sense, as an
integrated whole, can suffer death with the destruction of the means to have a true
and valid Supreme Pontiff, yet The Lord Jesus can remain in the Sacraments through
a less unified and somewhat disparate, yet validly ordained hierarchy.
N. de PlumeUn ami des Papes______