Print Friendly and PDF

by Stephen Wynne  •  •  March 12, 2019    133 Comments

Australian judge: Prelate’s ‘moral culpability’ is ‘high’

You are not signed in as a Premium user; we rely on Premium users to support our news reporting. Sign in or Sign up today!

MELBOURNE, Victoria ( – Three months after a jury found Cdl. George Pell guilty of sexually assaulting two boys, Australia’s leading prelate is heading to prison.

Inside a packed Melbourne courtroom Wednesday morning, Chief Justice Peter Kidd sentenced Cdl. Pell to six years in prison, while setting eligibility for parole at three years and eight months.

Justice Kidd said that by categorically denying the charges against him, Pell showed “no evidence of remorse or contrition” that would justify a reduction in punishment. In passing sentence, he acknowledged that the cardinal “may not live to be released from prison.”

Kidd began his nearly 90-minute address from the bench by denouncing the “witchhunt” to which Cdl. Pell had been subjected since accusations of abuse first sentenced against him. He went on to review in graphic detail the specific acts of abuse for which Pell was found guilty.

Condemning the cardinal for a grave “breach of trust and abuse of power,” Kidd described Pell as “a serious sexual offender” whose “brazenness” was brought on by an inflated “sense of power.” As a result of the sentence, Pell will be listed as a sex offender for the remainder of his life.

The cardinal plans to appeal Justice Kidd’s ruling. 

Pell was found guilty in December of sexually assaulting two boys in the sacristy of St. Patrick’s Cathedral in Melbourne in 1996.

According to the prosecution, after celebrating Mass one day in 1996, Cdl. Pell veered from his usual practice of greeting parishioners on their way out of St. Patrick’s Cathedral. Instead, he headed unaccompanied to the church sacristy where he discovered two choirboys who had separated themselves from their peers to indulge in altar wine. Catching them red-handed, prosecutors suggested, Pell decided to sexually assault the boys.

The cardinal has vigorously denied the allegations.Another red flag, Pell supporters note, is the fact that the reputation of Victoria Police has been sullied by charges of corruption.Tweet

Pell’s conviction provoked an outcry among many faithful Catholics, who insist the allegations against him are completely without merit. Supporters note that in 1996, the cardinal was actively involved in creating a response to the clerical sexual abuse crisis in Australia — despite criticism from some of the country’s bishops that he should wait — precisely because he thought the issue was so important.

They also point to the fact that during that period, Pell became a target of gay protesters owing to his outspoken criticism of homosexuality. 

Cdl. Gerhard Müller

Defenders also slam what they say is a suspicious lack of support for the cardinal inside the Vatican, in spite of the fact he is the third highest-ranking cleric in Rome.

Appointed prefect of the Secretariat for the Economy in 2014, Pell was brought in ostensibly to clean up Vatican finances, exercising oversight over the Holy See’s properties and personnel. But his proposed reforms — which included demands for greater transparency — were met with hostility.

According to Vatican expert Edward Pentin, the “Old Guard” resisted reform out of fears it would reveal their corruption.

Supporters continue to voice outrage over the fact that while serial sexual predator Theodore McCarrick is allowed to live out the remainder of his life in freedom at a central Kansas friary, Pell is locked away in solitary confinement. Pell, they insist, is no McCarrick.

“The allegations against him are absolutely unbelievable, it’s impossible,” said Cdl. Gerhard Müller, former prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, earlier this month. “It’s without proof, against all evidence. If there’s no proof, you cannot condemn a person to 50 years in a fortress.”

In a March 1 article for the National Catholic Register, Fr. Raymond de Souza echoed Müller, arguing the prosecution’s scenario beggars belief:

This [alleged assault] he accomplished immediately after Mass, with the sacristy door open, despite having all his vestments on and with the reasonable expectation that the sacristan, the master of ceremonies, the servers or concelebrants might come in and out or even pass by the open door, as would be customary after Mass. Meanwhile, there were dozens and dozens of people in the cathedral, praying or milling about. The whole affair took place within six minutes, after which the boys went off to choir practice and never spoke about it to anyone for 20 years, not even to each other. Indeed, one of the boys, who died of a heroin overdose in 2014, explicitly told his mother before he died that he had never been sexually abused.

“Ask any priest of a normal-sized parish — let alone a cathedral — if it would be possible to rape choirboys in the sacristy immediately after Mass,” de Souza challenged. 

“Sixty seconds — let alone six minutes — would not pass without someone, or several people, coming in and out, or at least passing by the open door,” he added. “Ask any priest if he is customarily alone in the sacristy immediately after Mass, while there are still people in the church and the sanctuary has not yet been cleared.”

Fr. Raymond de Souza

Another red flag, Pell supporters note, is the fact that the reputation of Victoria Police has been sullied by charges of corruption. According to a Victoria High Court, state law enforcement have “corrupted” prosecutions and “debased fundamental principles of the criminal-justice system.” 

In December, Premier Daniel Andrews announced the launch of a government inquiry into police wrongdoing and cover-up. 

Pell’s supporters argue the cardinal’s case is an outgrowth of this same police corruption. 

“The prosecution of Cardinal Pell has been a monstrous miscarriage of justice, a religious persecution carried out by prosecutorial means,” Fr. de Souza argued earlier this month. “The process that led to the convictions was, from the start, a sustained and calculated strategy to corrupt the criminal-justice system toward politically motivated ends.”

In a March 12 follow-up, de Souza pointed out

It has long been known, and now can be publicly reported, that the police in Victoria (Cardinal Pell’s home state in Australia) were out to get Cardinal Pell long before there were any complaints about him. They had set up a task force, “Operation Tethering,” in 2013 to search for charges against Cardinal Pell before any such complaints had ever been made to police.

They took out advertisements soliciting stories of sexual abuse at Melbourne’s St. Patrick’s Cathedral before any such complaints had been received. The Victoria police had their man and just needed to produce a victim and a complaint.

De Souza’s charge echoes an August 2016 piece in the journal Quadrant. In an article titled “The Relentless Pursuit of Pell,” Australian journalist Christopher Akehurst addressed the ongoing frenzy surrounding the cardinal.

“Who’s out to get George Pell?” Akehurst asked. “It looks as though someone is. … Is anyone orchestrating this ongoing pursuit?”

He also pondered what part Victoria Police had to play in the cardinal’s persecution:

In persisting with its investigation into Pell, secretly until someone leaked it, Victoria Police is in part demonstrating that a lot of thick coppers have signed up to the prevailing orthodoxy that Catholic priests must have some guilty sexual secret because celibacy, so out of tune with the mores of our age, denies them a “normal” outlet for their physical desires.

Akehurst concluded his article with an ominous takeaway: 

Pell is a thorn in the side of the leftish-minded within and without the Roman Catholic Church. I have heard people who wouldn’t know what a cardinal was sounding off against him. He is an orthodox Catholic who is not fuzzy or wishy-washy in expounding his faith. He has the additional stigma of being skeptical about man’s role in climate change. All in all, he’s out of step with the prevailing ethos of moral relativism. He has to be brought down.

About abyssum

I am a retired Roman Catholic Bishop, Bishop Emeritus of Corpus Christi, Texas
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.


  1. John Rayner says:

    The term “kangaroo court” has its foundation in Australia. This kind of court is alive and well there today as this “trial” of Cardinal Pell amply demonstrates. It is the kind of court where the accused is guilty before there is any trial. The evidence of just one complainant was sufficient to overide the evidence of twenty others that this so-called sexual assault was in fact impossible in an open sacristy and in the brief time that it is said to have occurred.
    A kangaroo court indeed.

  2. What a travesty! While numerous sodomite & enabling prelates are cruising around under the protection of PF & the Vatican, +++Pell is left to fight for his good name alone against a totally contrived claim by two young boys with no corroborating witnesses just the word of the accusers. The first accuser died from drugs but told his mother beforehand that he was not abused & the second one, now in his 30’s whose name was not disclosed, has been reported as saying his father was after the money. Investigators didn’t visit the scene of the alleged crime & some 20 people have testified to the impossibility of said assault being carried out in the circumstances put forward i.e. place, time, circumstances.

    At +++ Pell’s advanced age this is a life sentence yet, despite PF calling for abolishing life-long prison terms describing them as a “hidden death sentence”. he has not asked the Papal Nuncio to Australia to visit him. Neither have any other Cardinals or Bishops of the OHC&A Church seen fit to carry out this work of mercy to a fellow Brother. Apparently there’s one rule for sodomites & another for those upholding Catholic Doctrine. “The power of evil men lives on the cowardice of the good.” St. John Bosco.

Comments are closed.