Bishop Rene Gracida,
Thaddeus Mason Pope replied to your Tweet!
Bishop Rene Gracida
Bishop Rene Gracida @BishopGracida…

Thaddeus Pope is a promoter of the Third Path to passive euthanasia. – 27 Jan

Thaddeus Mason Pope @ThaddeusPope
Follow Follow

@BishopGracida There are good arguments (Shewmon, Truog..) to change brain death. But it is now the law, democratically ratified.

12:09 AM – 28 Jan 15

Reply to @ThaddeusPope
Retweet Favorite

“Brain death” statutes do not protect vulnerable citizens. All current legislation that establishes criteria of death based on cessation of functioning, function and functions of the brain should be repealed. Such patients have a beating heart with circulation and respiration and are not truly dead. At the very least such statutes should be amended so as: a) to substitute the words “complete destruction of the entire brain, including the brain stem” for such words as “irreversible cessation of functions of the brain”; and b) to require that the medical standards to be used be “universally accepted.”

This should be “the very least” since there is no proof that the destruction of the brain is equivalent to the death of the patient; medically speaking, such destruction is demonstrably not equivalent. There is no consensus as to which of the myriad criteria to use (Neurology 2008) and brain-related criteria are not evidenced based (Neurology 2010).

The Uniform Determination of Death Act should be rejected by all state legislatures and Congress since legalized alternative kinds of “death” which neither are nor are intended to be equivalent.

Paul A. Byrne, M.D.


About abyssum

I am a retired Roman Catholic Bishop, Bishop Emeritus of Corpus Christi, Texas
This entry was posted in BRAIN DEATH, SAVING CHILDREN, SCIENCE AND ETHICS, Uncategorized, WITNESS TO THE TRUTH and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.